On the border between France and Spain in the Pyrenees

On the border between France and Spain in the Pyrenees
According to legend, the Brèche was cut by Roland, supposedly a nephew of Charlemagne, with his sword Durendal, while attempting to escape the Saracens during the Battle of Roncevaux Pass. This geological gap, if you will, seems like an appropriate metaphor for my personal attempts at Sense-Making.

Saturday, December 6, 2008

Faith, Knowledge, Doubt, and Depression

Well, November came and went without a blog post, but I am not going to apologize as I was enjoying most of November back in Kansas with my family. I am back in Kent briefly to wrap up the semester and then heading back to the Land of Oz. So this may be the only post for December as well. It has been snowing since about noon and I am getting ready to go out to attend the Kent Festival of Lights, which brings me to the topic of this post. 


One of the things I have really had to monitor during the past several months of living alone is depression. It has been a recurring problem over the years, but this experience has been a strong motivator to deal with it more thoroughly than usual. I know that my nervous system tolerates only a cup of coffee per day. Any more than that I can usually start to feel the anxiety and depression building up. Thank goodness for decaf. Daily exercise is also vital for keeping my depression in check and I am thankful for a daily schedule that makes it easy to fit in 30-40 minutes most every day. I know that this time of year when there is less daylight and the nights are colder gets me down, which brings me back to the Festival of Lights.

I know that this is more of a commercial/festive event than anything spiritual, but it reminds me of the ancient rituals of turning back the night and leads me to the topic I have been pondering for a couple of weeks: where faith begins and knowledge ends. Another value in this equation for me, however, is doubt. 

I grew up believing that faith was more important than knowledge. Knowledge was valuable of course, but it was more important to believe that the end was near, that Jesus was coming back at any time, and only those strong in their faith would be whisked away to heaven, while all those who valued knowledge more than faith would be left behind to suffer. There came a point in my life when I rejected all of that and took up the power of doubt to liberate myself from the fear of unreasonable faith. But for me the price of liberation, the cost of skepticism, is having to accept  uncertainty and the occasional bout with depression. 

I am experiencing a new appreciation for folks who are able to believe, who have faith, but not at the expense of knowledge. I am encountering people who, while seeming not to doubt their faith, are at least being conscientious in their effort and obligation to continually extend their knowledge of the world. This has helped me to realize my error in assuming that people of faith tend to draw a circle within which they stand with their faith and are content to never venture beyond the circle into the unknown. I have also become aware of my lapse in questioning my own lack of faith, my drawing a circle around my doubts and refusing to venture into the world of faith. 

Faith continues to be irrational for me, but not any less so than whatever motivated the many parents I saw this evening bringing their kids out in the cold and the snow so the children could stand in line to tell Santa what they want for Christmas. It was good to see the smiles, to watch snow angels being made, and to just witness and appreciate the innocent belief children that life is good. I was reminded that, as a child, there still was uncertainty, but there was also faith that the adults in my life were in control and that everything was going to be okay. 

Then, of course, there comes a time when we have to be the adults and we come to realize how very scary it is to be the one who is supposed to make sure everything is going to be okay. The inability to make everything okay for everyone in my life is another cause of depression, but is not near as easy to control as limiting coffee intake or taking time to exercise. 

4 comments:

ellie skoutas said...

Dr. Roland,
On reading your post on faith, I notice you struggling with the choice between faith and knowledge.
One does not neccessarily pre-empt the other.
I have an almost obsessive need to gather information, often on the most inane subjects (it once took me a month to purchase a coffee maker while I researched the who what and why of how each type functions and what makes one better than the other). But I digress...
At the same time, my faith is what grounds me and gives me an unspoken reassurance that whatever is supposed to happen, will and does happen. I also believe that there is some force driving me on my quests for knowledge...it led me to the MLIS program when returning to school was not at the forefront of my agenda.
Your faith does not have to be blind or flag-waving....if you can "let go and let God" (sorry to sound preachy or trite...I'm really not), you'll find contentment. Have faith that you are driven to knowledge naturally, and there is no need to struggle with who you are...
Good Luck!

DRR59 said...

Ellie,

Thanks for your comment. The question for me is where does knowledge end and faith begin? Faith begins at the point where my knowledge is no longer helpful nor useful so that something then must be taken on faith.

My problem is when faith then becomes an excuse to cease the search for knowledge. I am perplexed and frustrated when a person refuses to think about a particular issue or question for whatever reason and simply dismisses the call the deal with the issue by reducing it to a matter of faith, when they fall back on something they believe just because somebody told them to believe it.

At the same time I recognize there is very little in life that we can "know" and that we more accurately act on our beliefs than our knowledge. As David Hume made plain, just because the sun has risen in the east every day in the history of the universe is no guarantee that it will do so tomorrow. We believe it will rise in the east tomorrow and prepare our lives on that belief, but we cannot know with certainty.

Have a great day.

ellie skoutas said...

Yes, I agree that blind faith is a poor excuse for anything.
Even the most learned persons in any faith never cease studying that faith (among other issues).
All things in moderation. You can have faith that something exists without opting out of life by relying solely on that "thing."
I am also equally annoyed by those that absolutely refuse to recognize or accept any idea outside of that faith...That is often just an excuse to judge.
My priest just recently quoted in an address "There are always two paths. One that is easy, and it's only reward is that it is easy."
Such is life and our daily existence..

DRR59 said...

It sounds like we are on a similar path. A favorite guide for me comes from Frederich Buechner: "Doubt is the ants in the pants of faith - doubt keeps faith alive and moving."